The Overlooked Excellence of the Canadian Premier League
The Canadian Premier League (CPL) is frequently seen by both its players and fans as a springboard to bigger leagues such as Major League Soccer (MLS) or opportunities overseas. However, the quality of competition and player development within the CPL deserves far more recognition than it typically receives.
Comparing CPL and MLS: Not as Far Apart as Many Think
Contrary to popular belief, the gulf between the CPL and MLS is much smaller than often assumed. While MLS teams generally have a stronger track record in direct clashes, some CPL sides have gone toe-to-toe with MLS opponents with impressive results. For example, Forge FC nearly outplayed Toronto FC in a Canadian Championship final, dominating the match and only losing in a penalty shootout. This suggests that the top CPL teams, such as Forge and Cavalry FC, could compete respectably in the MLS and likely outperform some of the league’s weaker clubs.
Top CPL Talent Ready for the Next Level
There are currently several standout CPL players who possess the talent, physicality, and football intelligence to excel in MLS or abroad. Many are not only capable of stepping up but would be considered above-average performers in these higher-profile settings. Here’s a selection of CPL stars who appear ready to make a significant impact beyond the league:
- Kyle Bekker
- Daniel Nimick
- Daan Klomp
- Alexander Achinioti-Jönsson
- Lorenzo Callegari
- Amer Didić
- Manny Aparicio
- Marco Carducci
- Diego Gutiérrez
- Alessandro Hojabrpour
- Ali Musse
- Zachary Fernandez
- Aidan Daniels
- Eryk Kobza
- Alejandro Díaz
In addition to these names, there are plenty of other CPL athletes who could easily fill important roles in more prominent leagues.
Key Characteristics of CPL’s Leading Players
When analyzing these top CPL prospects, some important patterns emerge:
- Ten of the fifteen highlighted players are Canadian, emphasizing the league’s commitment to developing homegrown talent.
- A notable proportion play as central midfielders or centre-backs—positions where versatility and tactical understanding are highly valued and often in demand.
- Several have prior MLS experience, suggesting that a return to the top North American league would be a natural progression for their careers.
Names like Kyle Bekker, Daniel Nimick, and Daan Klomp could not only compete in MLS but immediately strengthen many teams. Players such as Joel Waterman and Lukas MacNaughton have already shown that success in the CPL can lead directly to becoming key contributors in MLS squads.
Challenges to Retaining Elite Talent in Canada
Despite the CPL’s rising standards, many top performers may not stay in the league long-term. If players aspire to national team selection or larger contracts, a move overseas or to MLS seems necessary. The league’s original vision was to nurture Canadian talent domestically, yet the lure of increased exposure and opportunities abroad remains strong for ambitious professionals.
Success Stories and Missed Opportunities
Prominent CPL graduates like Victor Loturi and Dominik Zator have found success in European football, raising their profile and opportunities for international play. While these are promising examples of talent development, they also highlight a challenge: Canadian clubs often lose their best prospects just as they reach their peak, depriving local teams of continued growth and recognition.
The Path Forward: Valuing the CANPL as More Than a Stepping-Stone
It’s understandable that financial incentives and broader exposure draw many players toward leagues like the MLS. Yet, the CPL stands as a credible platform with a level of quality that rivals expectations and merits more esteem from fans and scouts alike. The league has already proven itself capable of producing top-tier talent and competitive clubs that can compete with established North American teams.
For young players and supporters, the Canadian Premier League isn’t just a transitional stage—it’s a proving ground where stars are born and the country’s soccer identity is shaped. The continued development and respect for the CPL will be crucial in elevating Canadian soccer on the global stage.
