Celebrating National Comic Book Day: America’s Top Comic Book Characters Revealed
Each September 25th, fans across the country unite to honor the vibrant, action-packed world of comic books. With nearly four in ten Americans regularly diving into the latest adventures through comic strips and graphic novels, the influence of comics—and their captivating characters—shows no sign of stopping. As superheroes and villains leap off the printed page into major movie franchises, public fascination continues to soar.
Unveiling America’s Most Popular Comic Book Heroes and Villains
To mark National Comic Book Day, a nationwide survey was conducted to determine which comic book characters have captured the hearts of Americans. Thousands of participants from all walks of life weighed in, casting votes for their favorite icons from both the Marvel and DC universes.
- Batman emerged as the leading character, taking the top spot in 34 states.
- Spider-Man stands as the most beloved Marvel superhero in the nation.
- The Joker leads as the most admired comic book villain.
- Marvel enjoys greater popularity overall, with 66.8% of fans aligning with its universe compared to 33.2% for DC.
Which Superhero Wears America’s Crown?
Comic books offer an endless cast of memorable characters, from might-powered heroes to cunning anti-heroes and villains. But when it comes to nationwide popularity, who truly stands out above the rest?
Topping the list, Batman claims the title of America’s favorite comic book character, earning top marks in 34 states (23.1% of overall votes). The enduring appeal of Gotham’s brooding defender may stem from his relatability—despite being a billionaire, he is a hero without superpowers, grounded in his humanity, determination, and flaws.
Securing second place is Spider-Man, favored by nine states (15.8%). His widespread appeal owes much to the character’s duality: a superhero balancing extraordinary powers with the everyday struggles of teenage life. This relatability, coupled with cinematic success, has turned Spider-Man into a nationwide favorite.
Wonder Woman lassoed her way to third place, capturing 5.7% of the vote. She is especially beloved in Hawaii and stands as a symbol of compassion, equality, and empowerment, inspiring generations with her unwavering code of honor and strength.
Fourth on the list is Superman, with 5.7% support among respondents. Debuting in 1938, Superman’s legendary “S” insignia and commitment to justice continue to inspire admiration, particularly in Vermont and West Virginia.
Finally, Wolverine claws into fifth place. Favored by 5.7% of those surveyed, especially in New Mexico, Wolverine is recognized for his animal instincts, regenerative abilities, and complexity as the X-Men’s most renowned anti-hero.
Who Is America’s Favorite Comic Book Villain?
No comic book saga is complete without its iconic antagonists. Villains add depth, drama, and intrigue to superhero stories—and fans are just as invested in these baddies as in the heroes.
The Joker, Batman’s arch-enemy and the Clown Prince of Crime, is the runaway favorite, with 28.7% of Americans choosing him as their top villain. The Joker’s chaotic nature, dark humor, and complex psychology have made him a timeless figure throughout pop culture.
Catwoman lands in the second spot, chosen by 11.3% of respondents. Her ambiguous moral code and frequent shifts between adversary and ally to Batman make her a particularly intriguing anti-hero.
Harley Quinn takes third place (10.5%), winning fans with her unpredictable blend of madness and self-determination. Originally introduced as the Joker’s accomplice, Harley’s antics—and personal growth—have earned her a devoted following.
Loki, the shape-shifting trickster from Marvel lore, ranks fourth, winning 8.3% of the vote. Known for his cunning and shifting alliances, Loki’s journey blurs the lines between villainy and redemption, making him one of the most compelling antagonists in comics.
Magneto, the formidable X-Men adversary whose magnetic powers and tragic backstory set him apart, rounds out the top five with 7.9%. His complex motivations blur the boundaries between villain and misunderstood hero, captivating Marvel fans across the country.
Marvel vs. DC: Which Universe Reigns Supreme?
The rivalry between Marvel and DC Comics goes well beyond print, extending into viral debates, movies, and fandom culture. So, who do fans support the most?
According to the survey, Marvel leads by a significant margin—66.8% of American respondents identify most with characters and teams from the Marvel universe. This group includes Spider-Man, Iron Man, the Avengers, and X-Men. In contrast, DC commands 33.2% loyalty, with icons like Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman rallying the charge.
How We Conducted the Research
The findings are based on a survey conducted in September 2023, involving 2,000 adults across the United States. The average participant was 37.4 years old. The demographic breakdown included 52.2% male, 45.4% female, 2.1% non-binary, 0.2% transgender, and 0.2% self-identified as ‘other.’
Usage Guidelines
You are welcome to reference or republish the data and visuals from this article for educational or non-commercial uses. Please provide appropriate credit and link back to this page to acknowledge the source.
