The NFL’s Toughest and Friendliest Fan Bases When It Comes to Referees
It’s a classic scene in football: fans rising from their seats, shouting at officials after a close call. Whether justified or not, scrutinizing referees is woven into the fabric of NFL fandom. But which teams have supporters most likely to vent their frustrations, and which stick up for the officials? At the halfway mark of the NFL season, a new analysis reveals which fan bases are most critical of referees—and which show unexpected positivity.
Study Overview: Analyzing NFL Fans’ Reactions to Officials
To uncover which NFL supporters are quickest to criticize (or defend) the officiating, thousands of X (Twitter) posts were analyzed. This sentiment analysis, covering the start of the 2024 NFL season through the end of October, breaks down the fan bases with the strongest opinions—both negative and positive—about NFL referees.
Main Insights from the Sentiment Analysis
- Top Complainers: Fans of the Cleveland Browns, Jacksonville Jaguars, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and Washington Commanders share the lead with the highest proportion of negative posts about refs.
- Los Angeles Rams fans place second, with 95.4% of sampled posts critical of the officials.
- Houston Texans supporters rank third, voicing blame in 92.2% of their posts on X.
- Most Supportive: Tennessee Titans fans top the list for positive comments, with 60% of their posts showing support or humor directed at referees.
Which NFL Fans Are Most Likely to Criticize Referees?
Leading the charge, fans of the Cleveland Browns, Jacksonville Jaguars, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and Washington Commanders showed unanimous negativity toward referees, with 100% of posts analyzed from each group expressing criticism or blame. Social media is filled with examples, from a Commanders’ supporter declaring, “Referees were terrible in the NFL yesterday,” to a Buccaneers fan lamenting, “The referee error swung the chances of the Buccaneers winning significantly.” These comments reflect passionate allegiances and an eagerness to defend their teams.
Not far behind, Los Angeles Rams fans proved almost as vociferous, with 95.4% of their posts slamming officiating. For example, after a controversial moment in an October matchup against the Vikings, Rams fans on X demanded accountability for what they saw as egregious missed calls—sometimes even siding with rival fan bases against the officials.
Houston Texans fans round out the top three most critical groups. In 92.2% of Texans-related posts, fans didn’t shy away from harsh judgments, calling referee crews the “worst ever” and outright blaming losses on officiating decisions. Patriots and Raiders supporters complete the top five, with more than 90% of their analyzed posts expressing outright dissatisfaction with in-game officiating.
Fan Bases Most Likely to Support or Joke with Referees
On the other end of the spectrum, Tennessee Titans fans stood out for their relatively positive attitude towards referees, with 60% of their posts either defending officials or making light, humorous comments. Memes, funny images, and playful nods to the referees were common, suggesting a more relaxed outlook—at least when it comes to complaining online.
Denver Broncos fans are nearly as forgiving, ranking second with 57.1% positive sentiment posts and sometimes even expressing appreciation. Steelers fans follow at third place, with over half (53.1%) of their online commentary directed at referees being upbeat or good-natured, such as teasing an official for flexing his biceps.
Within the top five most referee-friendly fan bases, Seattle Seahawks fans posted positively about referees 51.4% of the time, while Chicago Bears and Carolina Panthers fans showed perfect balance—half positive, half negative—when mentioning officials.
Summary Table: Top Critical and Supportive NFL Fan Bases
| Rank | Fan Base | % Negative Sentiment | % Positive Sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (tie) | Cleveland Browns | 100% | 0% |
| 1 (tie) | Jacksonville Jaguars | 100% | 0% |
| 1 (tie) | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 100% | 0% |
| 1 (tie) | Washington Commanders | 100% | 0% |
| 2 | Los Angeles Rams | 95.4% | 4.6% |
| 3 | Houston Texans | 92.2% | 7.8% |
| 4 | New England Patriots | 91.5% | 8.5% |
| 5 | Las Vegas Raiders | 90.9% | 9.1% |
| — | Tennessee Titans | 40% | 60% |
| — | Denver Broncos | 42.9% | 57.1% |
| — | Pittsburgh Steelers | 46.9% | 53.1% |
| — | Seattle Seahawks | 48.6% | 51.4% |
| — | Chicago Bears | 50% | 50% |
| — | Carolina Panthers | 50% | 50% |
What Drives the Conversation?
If there’s one thing uniting NFL fans, it’s their passion—and referees are often caught in the crossfire. For some, negative calls are a rallying point, fueling passionate online discussions and rants. For others, it’s a chance to share a joke or shrug off referee decisions with good humor. In every case, the intense loyalty to their teams explains the strong emotions behind every social post.
How the Analysis Was Conducted
The sentiment analysis was performed in November 2024 using Meltwater, a prominent social listening and monitoring platform. Researchers sifted through thousands of X (Twitter) posts referencing NFL referees, comparing positive and negative expressions from September 5 to October 31, 2024, across all fan bases to determine which fans were the quickest— or slowest— to criticize the officials.
Usage Guidelines
You are welcome to reference or reproduce the data and infographic featured here for non-commercial purposes, provided you include proper attribution and a link back to this page as the data source.
